We can’t ask the primates, other than ourselves, whether they want to take part in such experiments with them. Ivanov supervised the capture of adult chimpanzees in the interior of the colony, which were brought to Conakry and kept in cages in the botanical gardens. Originally Posted by laza and it would be one more gigantic proof in favor of evolution, maybe the biggest How would it be a “proof” of evolution?
Ok, c’mon people lets do it for science It would still be unethical, but heck, when has that stopped anyone? Chimp-hounds are really cute and a dog with hands could be trained to do interesting things. My name is Sandy and I am working on my teaching certification in Biology. How to Make A Humanzee – YouTube Check out this video by scishow, it says some stuff about it!
If we actually needed to preform this experiment, which I can’t see how we do, we would first attempt to cross breed other great apes. Any time you even so much as use human cells for experimentation, you’re talking about legal issues.If you tried to breed a human…come on. I am having a ton of trouble in the course of Genetics. Ivanov attempted to gain backing for his project from the Soviet government. Here, in the US, we call them Congressmen.
They decided that at least five volunteer women would be needed for the project. They already knew before leaving that the first two chimpanzees had failed to become pregnant. Short version: the ones that NEED “convincing” are never going to be convinced – their minds are made up because God told them what to think.The ones who already know don’t require further evidence (and it wouldn’t be evidence: scientists can do all sorts of stuff in labs – if people could understand why it’s “proof” they don’t need the experiment performing).Those who are in the middle ground aren’t going to be swayed by a Frankenstein’s monster – if they really want to know they’ll find out. No, thanks. Originally Posted by Neverfly No, thanks.
He returned to France where he arranged through correspondence with French Guinea’s colonial governor to set up experiments at the botanical gardens in Conakry.Ivanov reached Conakry in November 1926 accompanied by his son, also named Ilya, who would assist him in his experiments. Related Discussions:Portland ditches 140 million litres of drinking water after teenager caught urinating in reservoirPython mating seasonHurricane Center challenges to warn about SandyBigfoot?Best Fitness Monitoring DevicesThe Death Penaltykinematic problemsImagine WWIII starts : where is the safest country to go?”Gun-free Zones”Asteroids modified the early Earth In September 1925 Gorbunov helped allocate US$10,000 to the USSR Academy of Sciences (now the Russian Academy of Sciences) for Ivanov’s human-ape hybridization experiments in Africa.In March 1926 Ivanov arrived at the Kindia facility, but stayed only a month without success. If it criminal to deform the development of a human than is also criminal to also allow the development of a deformed human. Originally Posted by laza hammer to someone’s brain ? what are you talking about, this would be a big breakthrough and it would be one more gigantic proof in favor of evolution, maybe the biggest Past studies concluded the cross species breeding between the two wouldn’t likely work.
On February 28, 1927, Ivanov inseminated two female chimpanzees with his own sperm. Some things we can reasonably decide we don’t want to try just to confirm the results we suspect.For example, I have no desire to try crack/cocaine just to see what it’s like. But that is not the case, we want to see is it possible for a homo sapiens and a chimpanzee to have offspring, and what would that animal look like, the genetic details and yes intelligence Ivanov’s proposal finally sparked the interest of Nikolai Petrovich Gorbunov, the head of the Department of Scientific Institutions. A cruel faith, and consider it more than criminal to deform the development of a human deliberately.
The remaining chimps were sent to a new primate station at Sukhumi.Although Ivanov attempted to organize the insemination of human females with chimpanzee sperm in Guinea, these plans met with resistance from the French colonial government and there is no evidence such an experiment was arranged there.Upon his return to the Soviet Union in 1927, Ivanov began an effort to organize hybridization experiments at Sukhumi using ape sperm and human females. What are the consequences to the product of the hybrid if it ever was to happen? Would it be put on display as for the world to watch it grow in a zoo somewhere and be treated as some kind of oddity? We should not be tampering with such things just to see what would happen, that’s not good science to me.
It took years of battling just to find ways to work with stem cells. In the spring of 1929 the Society set up a commission to plan Ivanov’s experiments at Sukhumi. Once you can successfully breed chimp-atangs or Orang-orillas and the technology has been shown to work, then we could attempt the human crossbreed. On June 25, his son inseminated a third chimpanzee with his sperm.
It wouldn’t be ‘proof’ of anything. Originally Posted by laza why cant we get human chimp hybrids, has anyone ever tried , i heard that there were some experiments in the past, but were they serious ? Obviously yes, it has been tried. yes, because you can get addicted and die a horrible death, but this is different, in this case we will never know unless we test it, and it is a huge scientific question, and it would benefit greatly by increasing the acceptance of evolution around the world You probably will have to place a Thread in the Biology Forum to get the ball rolling. We sure do know how to screw things up rather well , don’t we. hammer to someone’s brain ? what are you talking about, this would be a big breakthrough and it would be one more gigantic proof in favor of evolution, maybe the biggest Some things we can reasonably decide we don’t want to try just to confirm the results we suspect.For example, I have no desire to try crack/cocaine just to see what it’s like. If there is anyone out there that can help me it would be greatly appreciated. I can make a pretty educated guess that it’s not something I want.
I would be totally against such a thing happening and see anyone trying to do this as someone who only wants attention for themselves, not for the advancement of science. I really do not know how to use this Science Forum but am attempting the trial and error method. The Kindia site, it turned out, had no sexually mature chimpanzees.
The Ivanovs left Africa in July with thirteen chimps, including the three used in his experiments. Also consider the probable psychological issues for the minders, after gaining a parents bond to the hybrid/deformed human. As early as 1910 he had given a presentation to the World Congress of Zoologists in Graz, Austria in which he described the possibility of obtaining such a hybrid through artificial insemination.In 1924, while working at the Pasteur Institute in Paris, Ivanov obtained permission from the Institute’s directors to use its experimental primate station in Kindia, French Guinea, for such an experiment.
I agree, I see no scientific breakthrough in this experiment, I could take a hammer to someone’s brain and get the same results. This would imply that not aborting a developmentally deformed human is criminal. I can make a pretty educated guess that it’s not something I want. you would have a point if we wanted to see an animal that is half retarded and that is all . If there is anyone out there that can and is willing to help, it would be very much appreciated.Thanks,Sandy Originally Posted by laza for the people that say we have no connection with other apes and we are a special kind E.g. the ones who don’t know what they’re talking about. it would be a little difficult to explain how can we mate with chimpanzees Quite simple: they’ll claim “it was done in a lab – scientists messed about with things, it doesn’t mean that we and chimps have anything in common any more than that experiment that produced a mouse with an ear on its back does”.
It seems very unethical as well. Hi, My name is Sandy. As this post demonstrates. Originally Posted by mvb Originally Posted by laza why unethical ? it would be a scientific breakthrough if it succeeded The life of the resulting offspring could be pretty horrible. i dont think that it would be on a par with the skateboarding parrot, but ok, maybe you are right, maybe we shouldn’t see it for the ethical reasons, but i would still like to see if it was possible If they’re not botheerd either way why “force it on them”?It would, in the end, be a news item on a par with the skateboarding parrot… yeah but that is what a really crazy ones would say, i was thinking about majority, the people who are not that insane or just uninformed and similiar, because this experiment would be heard around the world, and it would be expained to normal people Ilya Ivanovich Ivanov was the first to actually attempt to create a human–ape hybrid.
I’m saying I can strike someone’s cranium and cause the damage required to have similar intelligence to a chimp-man. The third died in France, and was also found not to have been pregnant. Originally Posted by krausyaoj There are some chimps who have language skills exceeding those of some humans. However, in June 1929, before any inseminations had taken place, Ivanov learned that the only postpubescent male ape remaining at Sukhumi (an orangutan) had died.
They’ll just cuss about it.The politics aside, and the ethics of it aside, we would not learn very much from a human chimp hybrid. Originally Posted by Dywyddyr Originally Posted by laza and it would be one more gigantic proof in favor of evolution, maybe the biggest How would it be a “proof” of evolution? for the people that say we have no connection with other apes and we are a special kind , it would be a little difficult to custom written research papers
explain how can we mate with chimpanzees Well that has to be morally unethical. A human-chimp hybrid would not be a deformed human no more than a horse-zebra hybrid is a deformed horse. Why not make a poll- use this forum as a small study sample. Is it worth what manner of life it would have, to simply see what we could reasonably surmise without actively crossing the species?
There are Members on this Science Forum that may be able to answer your Questions on Genetics in Biology. You are incorrect, chimps have been known to possess a greater intellect than mentally disabled individuals. It would be difficult, expensive, morally ambiguous, and just plain creepy.
Imagine the life of a being smart enough to know that it was clearly the dumbest human-like being on earth. The evidence in favor of evolution is already overwhelming.If they aren’t accepting that, they won’t accept a humanzee or whatever. The quality of an individual life does not depend on species as there are many animals that have a better quality of life than some humans.An interesting question is how much language ability would a human-chimp hybrid have? There are some chimps who have language skills exceeding those of some humans. A hybrid could simply be seen as a badly deformed human.
Eventually in 1929, through the help of Gorbunov, he obtained the support of the Society of Materialist Biologists, a group associated with the Communist Academy. I am currently working on my teaching certification in Biology and am having extreme difficulty in Genetics. A new set of chimps would not arrive at Sukhumi until the summer of 1930.source: wikiI just lost my faith to the humanity Welcome to The Science Forum aq2652. Definitely not something I would want.
Given the nature of its life, the question I’d stand by is the ethical one. He dispatched letters to the People’s Commissar on Education and Science Anatoliy Vasilievich Lunacharsky and to other officials. Not to be trite, but….huh?